Mennonite Christmas Cake (Fruitcake)

This easy Mennonite Christmas cake is a rich, moist, fruit-filled cake packed with memories. A thick batter mixed with raisins, cherries, fruit glace, and almonds make this a rich, flavourful cake that is impossible to resist.

Home » Recipes » Mennonite Christmas Cake (Fruitcake)

A Family Recipe

This is one of those recipes that was passed down over a text message. Something that previously existed only in memory or handwritten on a piece of paper in someone’s drawer.

Every Christmas holiday, everyone in my family looked forward to Christmas cake. For most of my life I was horrified that people would eat something like this. As a child I found it so unappealing, but then a few years ago I finally caved and tried it again .. I was immediately obsessed. I ended up taking a little loaf home and devouring it slowly over a couple of weeks.

The last few years, due to arthritis, it’s become difficult for my grandma to make this (it takes a lot of work to stir everything together), so my mom and I decided to take on the job. After a spectacular first attempt failure last year, lots of detailed notes, a remake ($$) and acceptable loaf last year – we have finally nailed it!

Now you might also be wondering what a Mennonite is .. well it’s not a Hutterite or Amish (though the “old order” Mennonites practice similar lifestyle choices). Mennonites are a sub-group of Christianity that believe in adult baptism (rather than infant), pacifism, frugality, hard work, and the separation of church and state.

Of course, there’s a lot more to the Mennonite faith than that, but those are the footnotes! Mennonites were often farmers, and you can find many groups of them in Saskatchewan (where my family is from) and the US.

What Makes This Christmas Fruitcake the Best

Obviously I’m biased because it’s my family’s recipe, but here are some reasons why I love it!

  • No alcohol fruitcake – yep, you heard that right! This is a kid-friendly cake, though I don’t think kids would eat it anyways.
  • No soaking or “feeding” required – most recipes require you to either soak the fruit for a long period of time or “feed” the cake with alcohol every few days. Not here! Except you do need to wait at least few weeks before you dig in.
  • Lasts forever in the fridge – maybe this isn’t appealing to everyone, but this fruitcake can (in theory) last up to a year in the fridge, but we’ve never had them last that long. See the section below on fruitcake shelf life.
  • Batch friendly – this recipe makes 6 loaves, meaning you can freeze a bunch of them and eat them next year or save them for another occasion.
  • Delicious – this cake is so good, and it doesn’t even need special spices, alcohol, or tricks. Flavour builds from its long “sit” in the fridge, but honestly it still tastes good that night! Howver, I promise waiting 2-4 weeks will be worth it.

Why Does Fruitcake Last So Long

Due to the high sugar content, it is nearly inhospitable to most microbes – add in the booze, and it becomes an even harsher place for bacteria1. In addition to the high sugar content, there’s an extremely low moisture (water) content in the dense, non-airy loaf. The ancient Romans took fruitcake with them into battle, acting as a little “energy bar” since it was shelf stable and high calorie2.

Not convinced? Read this article3 on fruitcake – some was eaten that was over 100 years old! The reason fruitcake has been such a popular dessert through the ages is its ability to stay safe to eat after months (and years) of refrigeration. Scary? A little. But its just science.

Using Glace Fruit Mix vs. Dried Fruits

To be honest, the fruit glace mix does scare me a bit, but there’s something about those sickeningly sweet and overly brightly coloured fruits that I love. They’re also key for a “traditional fruitcake”.

It may seem strange and a little different, but it’s also what makes this cake Mennonite to me. I recently found a book published in 1950 from Mennonite kitchens all over North America, and man, those people LOVED their sugar! This cake represents that excessive use (and love) of sugar in post-war food. I can’t help but love it, plus it’s totally nostalgic.

You certainly could try soaking some fruits in syrup or booze instead, but I recommend you give this traditional fruitcake a taste first.

Gluten-Free Christmas Cake

Lucky for you, this cake can be made gluten-free! Since there’s no gluten development needed and the cake is heavy, this is a perfect place to substitute for gluten-free.

No Name brand Glace Cherries and Deluxe Fruit Mix do not state gluten on the container – double check all ingredients before starting. Even some brands of baking powder can contain gluten, so always check.

All-purpose flour can be substituted for your favourite gluten-free flour blend. 

The shelf-life of the gluten-free fruitcake shouldn’t change4, but may be more prone to drying out. Wrap it well before storage and this may be a good option for soaking/brushing with a gluten-free friendly liquor like rum, brandy, cognac, or bourbon/whisky. Pure distilled alcohol is gluten-free by nature, but be careful of additives or certain barrels being used during aging.

How to Make Mennonite Christmas Fruitcake

Before starting, please ensure all your wet ingredients are *room temperature*, otherwise the butter will harden and separate from the mixture. This is very important!

Preheat the oven to 250°F and prepare your baking pans. Cut long strips (2-3″x12″) and place lengthwise in the loaf tins. They should not go up the sides except on the short side. This will allow you to lift them from the tins when cool.

Wet Ingredients

1.) Add 1 lb room temperature butter and 1 ½ cups white sugar to the bowl of a stand mixer or a large bowl.

2.) Beat until light and fluffy before adding in 7 room temperature eggs, one at a time.

    3-4.) Once all the eggs are incorporated, whisk in ½ cup room temperature orange juice and 2 tsp vanilla extract. Set aside. The mixture may separate a bit, this is normal.

    Fruit Mix

    5.) In an extremely large bowl, stir together 2 lbs deluxe glace fruit mix (2 containers), 3 lbs red glace cherries (3 containers), 2 lbs raisins (I did a mix of Thompson and golden), and 2 ½ cups (460 g) slivered almonds. Set aside.

    Dry Ingredients

    6.) Stir together 4 cups all-purpose flour, 2 tsp baking powder, 1 tsp fine sea salt, and ½ tsp baking soda. Add the flour mixture into the fruit mix and stir well to combine. You will likely need a large metal spoon/utensil to do this. Once combined, stir in the wet ingredients.

      7.) Once all the ingredients are well mixed, divide evenly among the 6 prepared loaf tins. Press down gently until they’re somewhat flattened on top and no large gaps on the sides remain.

      Baking

      8.) Bake at 250°F for 2 hours and 45 minutes directly on the rack or on a sheet pan with a cooling tray. Rotate halfway through. Increase the temperature to 275°F for another 15 minutes before removing all of the loaves to a wire rack to cool completely.

      Once cooled completely, wrap tightly in plastic wrap and place in an airtight container or bag in the fridge. Let it sit and age for 4-6 weeks before serving.

        Serving and Storing

        Once its cooled off, we wrap it in plastic wrap and leave it in the fridge for 4-6 weeks before consuming. It lasts another few weeks in the fridge after that (if you don’t eat it all), and in theory for months. Freeze up to one year tightly wrapped in plastic wrap and in an airtight bag. Thaw overnight in the fridge and enjoy as usual!

        If you’re nervous about shelf life, try wrapping the loaf in a cheesecloth soaked in rum or brandy. Change out/re-soak the cheesecloth every few weeks. The alcohol will contribute to preserving the fruitcake.

        I’m not sure why our cake isn’t filled with rum or brandy, but honestly I don’t think it needs it! This makes the cake a bit more family friendly, but also easier since you aren’t needing to drizzle alcohol over it every few days.

        Other Holiday treats you may enjoy

        Mennonite Christmas Cake
        Author: Laurel Braun

        Mennonite Christmas Cake

        No ratings yet
        This easy Mennonite Christmas cake is a rich, moist, fruit-filled cake packed with memories. A thick batter mixed with raisins, cherries, fruit glace, and almonds make this a rich, flavourful cake that is impossible to resist.
        Prep Time 1 hour 30 minutes
        Cook Time 3 hours
        Total Time 4 hours 30 minutes
        Course: Baked Goods, Dessert
        Cuisine: American, Global Cuisine
        Servings: 6 cakes

        Ingredients
         
         

        Wet Ingredients
        • 1 lb salted butter, room temperature
        • 1 ½ cups white sugar
        • 7 large eggs, room temperature
        • ½ cup orange juice, room temperature
        • 2 tsp vanilla extract
        Fruit Mix
        • 2 lbs deluxe glace fruit mix, (2 containers)
        • 3 lbs red glace cherries, (3 containers)
        • 2 lbs raisins
        • 2 ½ cups slivered almonds
        Dry Ingredients
        • 4 cups all-purpose flour
        • 2 tsp baking powder
        • 1 tsp fine sea salt
        • ½ tsp baking soda

        Equipment

        • 6 tinfoil loaf pans
        • Stand Mixer or hand mixer
        • 6 parchment paper sheets
        • extra-large bowl for mixing

        Method

          Before starting, please ensure all your wet ingredients are *room temperature*, otherwise the butter will harden and separate from the mixture. This is very important!
        1. Preheat the oven to 250°F and prepare your baking pans. Cut long strips (2-3"x12") and place lengthwise in the loaf tins. They should not go up the sides except on the short side. This will allow you to lift them from the tins when cool.
        Wet Ingredients
        1. Add the butter and sugar to the bowl of a stand mixer or a large bowl. Beat until light and fluffy before adding in the eggs, one at a time.
        2. Once all the eggs are incorporated, whisk in the orange juice and vanilla. Set aside. The mixture may separate a bit, this is normal.
        Fruit Mix
        1. In an extremely large bowl, add the glace cherries, deluxe fruit mix, raisins, and almonds. Set aside.
        Dry Ingredients
        1. Stir together the flour, baking powder, salt, and baking soda.
        2. Add the flour mixture into the fruit mix and stir well to combine. You will likely need a large metal spoon/utensil to do this.
        3. Once combined, stir in the wet ingredients. Once all the ingredients are well mixed, divide evenly among the 6 prepared loaf tins. Press down gently until they're somewhat flattened on top and no large gaps on the sides remain.
        Baking
        1. Bake at 250°F for 2 hours and 45 minutes directly on the rack or on a sheet pan with a cooling tray. Rotate halfway through. Increase the temperature to 275°F for another 15 minutes before removing all of the loaves to a wire rack to cool completely.
        2. Once cooled completely, wrap tightly in plastic wrap and place in an airtight container or bag in the fridge. Let it sit and age for 4-6 weeks before serving.

        Notes

        **All ingredients must be room temperature prior to starting**
        Gluten-Free Substitutions: No Name brand Glace Cherries and Deluxe Fruit Mix do not state gluten on the container – double check all ingredients before starting. All-purpose flour can be substituted for your favourite gluten-free flour blend. Click the link for more information.
        christmas recipes, freezer friendly, gluten-free option, holiday recipes, kid friendly, oven, vegetarian, winter recipes

        Tried this recipe?

        Let us know how it was!
        1. https://www.mcgill.ca/oss/article/health-and-nutrition-did-you-know/why-do-fruitcakes-last-so-long ↩︎
        2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fruitcake ↩︎
        3. https://theconversation.com/the-magnificent-history-of-the-maligned-and-misunderstood-fruitcake-173201 ↩︎
        4. https://www.kingarthurbaking.com/recipes/gluten-free-fruitcake-recipe ↩︎


        Leave a Reply

        Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

        Recipe Rating